Twitter Listens to Its Users: Kills the #DickBar


Twitter finally listens to its users and promises to remove the QuickBar from the next update of its iPhone app.

When Twitter launched the latest version of its official iPhone app, it added a new feature, the QuickBar, that displayed trending topic to the top of the user’s timeline. The problem with this feature was that just seeing the trending topics provides close to no value for most users, yet the QuickBar took up valuable screen estate. Many also felt that this was just a sneaky way to push “promoted trends” (Twitter’s version of ads) into a user’s timeline (as I said at the time, if a trend has to be promoted, it isn’t much of a trend). Thankfully, though, Twitter has finally listened to its users and today, the company announced that it will remove the so-called QuickBar from its app in the next update.

According to Twitter, the QuickBar – which its users quickly dubbed the DickBar in honor of Twitter CEO Dick Costolo – “was originally conceived to help users discover what’s happening in the broader world beyond people they already follow.” Interestingly, Twitter also notes that it wasn’t just meant to highlight trending topics, but that the company’s designers also though of it “as a potential means of in-app notifications for new @, DMs, and other important activity.” I can’t remember that Twitter ever communicated this broader goal for the QuickBar before and I also can’t help but wonder if its users’ reaction would have been different if Twitter had explained this before.

Twitter Saw “Incredibly High Usage Metric for the QuickBar”

As for the success of the QuickBar, Twitter notes that it likes to test features and then removes them “if we learn it doesn’t improve the user experience or serve our mission” – yet at the same time, the company’s blog post also states that it saw “incredibly high usage metrics for the QuickBar.”

10:11 am

Twitter Reacts to the #Dickbar Uproar: Not Killing It – Just Making it a Little Bit Less Annoying


When Twitter launched the latest version of its iPhone app a few days ago, most users were more than happy to get auto-completion for names and hashtags, among many other improvements. The fact that Twitter now prominently featured the top trending topics in its app – including the promoted trends that Twitter gets paid for – was, according to many users, a major negative of this version and was seen as a sneaky way to push ads to users without delivering any additional value. Some, including the intrepid Apple-watcher John Gruber, even went as far as reverting back to an older backup of their iPhone to get the old version back.

Today, however, just as the complaints gained steam thanks to the #dickbar hashtag on Twitter itself (named after Twitter’s CEO Dick Costolo), the company’s self-described “communications guy” Sean Garrett announced that Twitter had already submitted a new version of the app to Apple yesterday “that makes it so the quick bar doesn’t overlay on Tweets.”

While the fact that the quick bar was often blocking the view of some tweets was indeed annoying, the problem here is that the whole concept of the quick bar is annoying to begin with. Indeed, most of the complaints I’ve seen so far have more to do with the existence of the quick bar in the first place and not the way the trends were displayed.

Instead of just fixing this minor bug, Twitter should just make it either optional or giving users a way to pay for the app to make it go away. It’s understandable that Twitter wants to push promoted trends (though, of course, the fact that they have to be promoted means they aren’t really trends to begin with…). In a tweet he posted a short while ago, however, Twitter CEO Dick Costolo argued that giving users the option to turn this feature off would be an “inelegant implementation.” In other tweets, including this one directed at Robert Scoble, he  also argued that Twitter should have left the promoted tweets out of the quick bar.

The underlying problem here (more so than the inelegant implementation) seems to be that Twitter thinks there is value in seeing these trends, while for many users, they are simply useless reminders of the fact that there are a lot of Justin Bieber and Charlie Sheen fans on Twitter, too.


Of course, there are also multiple other Twitter clients for iOS that you could use if you don’t like the official ones. Among the best are the Seesmic app and Echofon.

7:27 pm